The honest truth about how to divide perennials – The Middle-Sized Garden

April 19th, 2020 Posted In: Gardening know how

Do your eyes glide over the advice to ‘divide perennials’ in spring and autumn?

I always used to think that dividing perennials was for perfect gardeners. My relaxed attitude to gardening meant I could skip such suggestions. I was wrong.

And I worried that if I dug up a plant and split it, I would damage it. The plant might die.

And I was wrong about that, too. In fact, a plant is very unlikely to die after being divided. Plants want to survive. Provided you take a few simple precautions, they will happily go back in the soil and start spreading again.

Even if you cut across a root, the plant will survive providing there is enough extra root around it. And there will be. I promise. By the time plants need dividing, they have usually trebled in volume. You will have plants to spare.

Why you really do have to divide perennials

Many perennial plants – those which come back year after year – spread. You plant one plant. Over two or three years, it expands, growing new corms, tubers, rhizomes or roots under the ground, all around the original plant.

Then the original plant dies off. So you have a large circle of plants with a bald patch in the middle. This is then colonised by weeds and self-seeding plants. I love self seeders, so this is another reason why I haven’t worried too much.

However my borders are now an illustration of John Lennon’s saying ‘life is what happens while you’re making other plans.’ They are, frankly, a muddle. There are clumps of plants invading other clumps of plants and bald patches full of weeds.

Because some perennials are thugs. Their relentless desire to take over territory makes them the Genghis Khan of plant world. So when you buy other plant, they disappear under the relentless march of day lilies, iris sibirica, phlomis and Japanese anemone.

In contrast, shrubs and roses stay where you planted them. They might get big – even very big. But they won’t go invading the rest of the garden, suppressing precious things you planted.

When to divide perennials

You can divide perennials in spring or autumn. If you do it in the summer or the winter, you’ll probably subject the plant to too much hot dry weather or cold, wet soil. Either will stress it.

And don’t divide plants when they’re flowering. I divide irises just after they’ve flowered, which is June (yes, even I divide irises or I would have nothing else in the garden!). But all the other plants can be divided in spring or autumn/fall.

And that’s about all you need to know about when to divide perennials. If you look up advice on specific plants, some experts advise spring over autumn or the other way around. Although some of that advice seems to be inconsistent.

So, if you’re an imperfect gardener like me, just avoid dividing perennials in summer or winter.

My mistake, over the years, has been to think ‘it’ll be better to wait until spring/autumn.’ In gardening it is never better to wait. Because plants go on growing.

How to divide perennials

Firstly, you simply dig them up. Our ground has been very hard recently, so I watered a clump of Siberian irises before trying to dig them up.

I poked my spade in. But the Siberian irises have been there for years. They had no intention of coming out without a fight.

So I got Mr Middlesize to dig them up. He thought I was digging them up to throw them away. So as the plants came out of the ground he shook them vigorously to dislodge the soil around the roots and hurled them over his shoulder.

By the time I noticed this harsh treatment, the Siberian irises lay in an ignominious pile on the lawn. This is not what dividing perennials looks like on the Alan Titchmarsh video.

However, it hasn’t done the Siberian irises any harm at all. They come from Siberia, after all (do they?).

So the first honest truth about how to divide perennials is this. Prepare for lots of huffing and puffing to get some of them out of the ground. And don’t worry about hurting them. You’re much more likely to hurt yourself (see here for advice on preventing back and knee pain when gardening.)

When we divided our Nepeta Six Hills Giant last autumn, Mr Middlesize eventually took an axe to one of the clumps to get it out of the ground.  The Nepeta are now re-planted, re-invigorated and bursting with new shoots.

Tease the roots apart gently

Forgive me for laughing at this point. It is a laugh of desperation. Titchmarsh et al can no doubt tease roots apart. He can do many things I can’t. But the instruction for us humbler mortals should be ‘wrestle the roots apart’.

If that doesn’t work, you are advised to use a spade. You chop neatly down, dividing the clump of plant into several smaller plants, all about the size they would be if you were buying them in a 3 litre pot in a garden centre.

In fact, you place your spade carefully where you want to cut. You use your foot to jam down the spade.

Nothing happens. You are left wobbling on top of a clump of Siberian irises that have no intention of dividing. Eventually you jump off the spade before you fall off. Someone else in the household tries. That doesn’t work either.

You can also use a knife, say the experts. So we used a knife to cut through a very small amount of root. It wouldn’t go through the main clump but we made some headway on the outside.

By combining the three methods, we eventually manage to separate three iris clumps from the main plant. Two thirds of the iris stayed solidly stuck together.

At some point in all this I realised my trousers had split up the back. But I cut that bit from the video.

Replant immediately

I really wanted to go for a lie down at this point, but all the advice says ‘re-plant immediately.’

Treat the plants as if you had just bought them. Water them well. Check how far apart they need to be when planted. According to the internet, Siberian irises need to be 8″-12″ apart, so I returned the three small clumps to the space where there had been a large circle with a bald patch.

Add fertiliser

I added a few handfuls of blood, fish and bone fertiliser, as suggested by experts. The dog started eating from the top of the soil.

Water well

This helps the plants get established. It also washes the remains of the blood, fish and bone fertiliser into the soil, which stops the dog eating it.

If you have a very dry spell, you probably need to carry on watering the newly planted plants until their roots get properly established.

Which perennials need dividing?

There are a huge number of perennials which need dividing every few years. If you stay on top of it, you’ll probably find it easier than I did.

Perennials to divide include plants that clump up, like ornamental grasses, Siberian irises, phlomis and asters (symphyotricum). A friend of mine has just been grappling with dividing heleniums ( I think she had to jump off a wall onto the spade to get the roots to slice apart. I do not recommend this approach).

The ‘divide perennials’ list includes plants with rhizomes, such as irises or cannas. Plants with tubers, such as day lilies, also need dividing from time to time.

The general principle for all the different types of plants is the same. Dig them up. Divide them with any implement that will work. Don’t worry about cutting across one or two roots. Replant immediately with some fertiliser and a good watering.

Don’t divide…

There are some plants that come into the ‘divide perennials’ list but which experts don’t agree on. For example, some people suggest you divide peonies. Others don’t. None of my peonies spread, so I don’t see the need to divide them.

I suggest you follow own instincts on this one. If a plant has spread out into a circle with a bald patch in the middle and is taking over other plants, lift and divide it.

And, of course, if you’re trying to fill a large border inexpensively then plants that spread are the key to easy successful gardening. Plant those perennials and let them fill your empty gaps. You may not have to divide perennials for several years.

I am just warning you that the day will come. Arm yourself with a range of implements, a strong friend and a stiff gin.

I sometimes thinking that dividing perennials is one of the jobs that makes people sell their homes because the ‘garden is getting too much for them.’ Let me recommend finding a professional gardener. Pay them properly for their expertise. Even then, it will be cheaper than moving.

What to do with the remaining plants

You will probably be left with a half to two-thirds of the clump, rhizomes or tubers. You can give them to friends, but they themselves may be clearing out their more thuggish plants.

There may be a community border near you who would like them. Or you can pot up the plants and donate them to charity plant sales. Just remember to pick out any weed roots and label the plants.

Otherwise, you may have to throw them away. I am not entirely sure whether they will compost well, as I suspect the plants will grow through your veg peelings and grass cuttings. But provided you keep cutting the foliage off and covering them with more garden waste, they will eventually give up and turn into garden compost.

The Complete Guide to Garden Privacy

Just in case you’re interested in improving your garden privacy or creating a secret garden feel, may I mention my book The Complete Guide to Garden Privacy? It’s available in paperback in 10 countries or Kindle in 13 countries from Amazon or as a PDF download for those who want to read on a tablet or pc but don’t use Kindle.

Pin to remember how to divide perennials

And do join us every Sunday morning for tips, ideas and inspiration for your garden.